Tuesday, February 10, 2009

Lights, Camera, Action or Inaction

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

I love a good conspiracy. Not one of those where people sit around and conjure up stories about how events that are difficult to fathom, were actually complicated and massive plots or cover-ups, perpetrated on unwitting citizens by secret government cabals. Nor do I mean the kind found in the first definition of the word to conspire; to do something illegal.

No. What I’m talking about is a group of people who actually sit around, over a cup of coffee, talking and listening to each other’s ideas, and coming up with a collective way to make substantial governmental change.

The secondary meaning of the word conspiracy is working together or plotting to cause a desired result or change to the detriment of another.

One such group in town is actually called, “ConspiracyBrews,” named, tongue in cheek, more for the coffee than any conspiracy. The detriment this group seeks, is towards closed and secret governmental power.

ConspiracyBrews is the brainchild of three-term New Mexico State Representative Janice Arnold-Jones, a Republican from Albuquerque’s Northeast Heights District 24, Bernalillo County.

In the past two election cycles Arnold-Jones, here, with her husband, John, at the 2007 opening of the Legislature, has faced no opposition, in either the primary or general elections.

As a matter of complete disclosure, a little more than two years ago I was introduced to Arnold-Jones by Harold Morgan, right, editor of Capitol Report New Mexico, who was then helping her campaign communications efforts.

I aided her by making a campaign photograph. Since then, I have responded to her queries. She is a faithful reader of this blog.

About ten months ago, Arnold-Jones realized that she had no opponent for her legislative seat, but didn’t want the election to pass without the opportunity to campaign. I suggested that she run as if she had an opponent: to walk her district, meet with her constituents one-on-one, and to hold office hours, open to anyone. She had held a “community discussion on ethics,” on Dec. 6, 2007, that was deemed successful. Why not do more?

Without opposition, she was free to raise issues of public concern that might otherwise be politically sensitive in heated contested races. I promised I would attend her open meetings and would not allow them to get dull.

That was the start. Arnold-Jones gathered her small, but dedicated group of campaign volunteers and her district’s Party members and others she had met along the way, inviting them to coffee at Cup O Joe’s on Saturday mornings.

The weekly meetings started small, but the conversations were lively. The group was encouraged to bring a friend under each arm and the numbers slowly grew.

The number attending fluctuates each week, but averages about 30; there are around 15 attendees who regularly participate. All are welcome, party doesn’t matter, neither does residency, you don’t have to live in the Representative’s district to be welcomed.

The group has Republicans, Democrats, Independents, and Libertarians. Within those larger groups, we find the complete political spectrum. When was the last time you heard the theories of the John Birch Society espoused? We’ve even got them.

The group brings together a divergent mix; here regular Mike Meyer, left, who announced his intention to run for the State Republican Party Chairmanship at the meetings, speaks with occasional visitor Harvey Yates, Jr., on Dec. 27, 2008, about his possibly entering the race. Yates would enter and beat Meyer, John Padovan, right, is another occasional visitor, and Dr. Allen McCulloch, from Farmington who has not attended, though he was invited.

Public Regulation Commissioner Jason Marks, a Democrat, above, visited recently and spoke about attempts for his body to be more open through technology.

Former Secretary of State’s elections chief Daniel Ivey-Soto, right, a Democrat, attends and contributes, especially on poll, election and ballot issues.

So what’s wrong with this picture?

In order to better understand, I present a roster of some of our group.

In no way do I mean to slight anybody who attends, by not mentioning them, because even the quiet ones add to the group dynamic.

I am going to limit this discussion to a group responsible for last couple of week’s number one legislative story; the use of a webcam by Arnold-Jones to show workings of the House Taxation and Revenue and the House Rules and Order of Business Committees.

The video coverage I present in this posting is not gavel to gavel, but an edited version of a selection of the full comments of members of the House Rules committee. I present the video this way to demonstrate that there are ways of presenting information without having the entire debate or being limited only to a television news sound bite.

This is Ched MacQuigg, above, covering the House rules committee for the blog spot he writes, Diogenes' Six. I provide pictures for MacQuigg's site.

You’ll remember Diogenes from your Greek mythology. He was considered one of the great Greek Cynic philosophers. He lived naked in a rain barrel. Diogenes, it is told, wandered Athens, during the day, with a lantern seeking a human being, others say he sought an honest man. MacQuigg’s site pays homage to Diogenes and “Six” indicates guarding the philosopher’s back, a fighter pilots reference to location based on the face of an analogue clock.

MacQuigg’s main focus is on his former employer, the Albuquerque Public Schools.


He has been most active in striving to hold the current Superintendent Winston Brooks, APS Board and top administrators accountable to ethical standards.

MacQuigg had a career as an APS shop teacher.

He also was an original member of Albuquerque educators who participated in a Character Counts, "train the trainers" seminar put on by the Josephson Institute's Center of California.

“It was a life altering event,” MacQuigg said. He has inculcated the philosophy of Character Counts and became an ethics advocate.

He demands adults at APS live to the same standards that students are being taught.

Over time, the APS Board of Education has distanced itself from the fundamental philosophical underpinnings and refuses to hold themselves to the ethical standards identified by Character Counts.

MacQuigg challenged his school’s leadership for not enforcing rules against students.

He was disciplined and wrongly terminated. APS reinstated him, but about four months later he left APS when they bought out his retirement.

Two years ago, MacQuigg ran for the School Board but lost to current member Martin Esquivel.

He takes every opportunity to call for ethical conduct and has used a variety of techniques to attempt to engage the Board in a civil conversation.

"The Board was refusing to talk about the elephant in the room," MacQuigg said, so he wore a homemade mask in silent protest.

He has been arrested by APS police, though not charged, more than a handful of times, for raising questions that either an administrator, board member or bureaucrat, who gave the police the high sign after deeming his comments off limits.

APS Board meetings are recorded and broadcast on the educational cable access channel. MacQuigg has had problems reaching the wider audience as technical audio gremlins have plagued him, in particular, when he speaks.

MacQuigg is on the right path; he just doesn’t have much of a public following.

Last summer before the Special Session of the Legislature, a ConspiracyBrews discussion was contemplating ways to get the public’s interest in the issues facing the state. If you recall, a tax rebate was the key issue, with Gov. Bill Richardson wanting to give money back to every taxpayer.

There was a concern that the idea was not very wise, as gas and oil revenues were very high, but there was an uncertainty about them staying at record rates.

MacQuigg suggested that thousands of angry citizens armed with torches and pitchforks storm the steps of the Capitol demanding openness and accountability. I suggested updated technology; video cameras throughout the galleries, edited together and posted on the Internet. There was an interest; though nothing was accomplished during the special session, an even newer technology emerged; webcasting.

A team of assistants helped Arnold-Jones acquaint herself with the Internet based technology.

Arnold-Jones is practicing operating the webcam during a ConspiracyBrews gathering Jan. 24, with the assistance of Charlie Christmann, running his webcam while streaming through a laptop computer. Christmann’s website is CivicPlaza.Net, the catch phrase, “Taking Back Our Country One Politician at a Time,” hosts and archives both the ConspiracyBrews meetings starting Jan 16. and the legislative committees.

Howard DeLaCruz-Bancroft, in the background operates his webcam at the Jan. 24, Saturday morning office hours meeting, ConspiracyBrews gathering. Arnold-Jones is being interviewed on her cellular phone about her planned webcasting of State Legislature activities. The interview was with radio talk show "Speaking Freely" hosted by Jim Scarantino and featuring Paul Gessing, last Sat. at 9 a.m. on JOY AM 1550, Albuquerque.

DeLaCruz-Bancroft opened a second website, NMGOV.TV to host Arnold-Jones’ webcasting efforts. The second site is a non-partisan hosting location.


New Mexico’s State Legislature is one of only three States that do not provide either audio or video coverage of their sessions, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. The three are: Arkansas, West Virginia, and New Mexico.

Yet the University of New Mexico owned, KUNM FM 89.9. Radio started to webcast House and Senate floor sessions on their website.

A commercial venture, New Mexico Legislative Report, has also posted a free link to both the House and Senate audio. This service had been available by subscription.

Others argue that the number of states not webcasting or televising legislative sessions is higher. Cable-Satellite Public Affairs Network’s website indicates that, as many as nine states do not meet their definition of webcasting or televising. They are: Arkansas, Delaware, Hawaii, Massachusetts, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Vermont, and West Virginia.

“New Mexico is one of only six states that doesn't webcast legislative proceedings,” The New Mexican’s Political Reporter Steve Terrell wrote, January 19, in his article headlined, “Budget crunch delays session webcasting: New Mexico one of six states without service.”

Sen. Mark Boitano, R, Bernalillo County, left, introduced Senate Memorial 45 in February 2008. The Memorial reinforced a 2005 piece of legislation instructing the Senate to start webcasting, but was never implemented.

Boitano’s Memorial stated:
…the New Mexico legislative council, at its January 14, 2008 meeting, declined to direct staff to issue a request for proposals to solicit bids so that webcasting could begin…

…legislative council service be requested to proceed as expeditiously as possible with the necessary arrangements and contracts to ensure that the proceedings of the senate will be streamed on the internet beginning in 2009,
The Senate’s roll call vote in February 2008, was 27-13.

The Senate’s Committees Committee voted to delay implementation, citing the budget crunch. Those voting in the committee included the Senate’s Democratic leadership: President Pro Tem Tim Jennings, Chavez, County, below center, and Majority Leader Michael Sanchez, below left, Valencia County. Other Democrats voting against the cameras were Senators: Phil Griego, Los Alamos, Mora, Sandoval, San Miguel, Santa Fe, and Taos Counties, Linda Lopez, Bernalillo County, Mary Kay Papen, Dona Ana County, and John Sapien, Sandoval County.

Minority Leader Stuart Ingle, right, Chaves, Curry, De Baca, and Roosevelt Counties was joined by fellow Republican Senators: Vernon Asbill, Eddy and Otero Counties, Gay Kernan, Chaves, Curry, Eddy, Lea, and Roosevelt Counties, and Carroll Leavell, Eddy and Lea Counties, in opposing the cameras.

Terrell, in his blog, Roundhouse Roundup, reported seeing a Capitol maintenance worker removing the cameras from the Senate chambers on Jan. 13, only a week before the opening of the regular 60-day session.

The physical removal of the cameras from the walls and the accompanying unstated message it sent, that there would be no open coverage; caused the ConspiracyBrews participants to focus interest on providing an alternative source of information to the citizens of the state.

Arnold-Jones, with House Minority Leader Tom Taylor, R, San Juan County, at an off session Dec. 18, 2008, Legislative meeting, determined that she would step into the breach and provide streaming video from the legislature. She carefully selected how she would proceed; reading the rules and determining the best course of action. She decided she would stream only the committee meetings of which she is a member.

Stepping forward posed certain risks and likely criticism. To avoid possible recrimination, I recommended preemptively establishing internal rules for operating the camera.

Arnold-Jones asked me to wordsmith a statement to be used on the website accompanying the webcast. Using the 30-year old Cable-Satellite Public Affairs Network as a model, and based on my experiences with the Bernalillo County/City of Albuquerque’s government access cable channel GOV-TV 16, I drafted a statement.
This web cast is provided to my constituents to raise public awareness and help educate citizens on the Legislature’s activity.

Web castings protocol is simple:

It is nonpartisan,
The picture follows sound, meaning the legislator or witness viewed is the person recognized by committee chair or the Speaker of the House.

Nothing shown or recorded on the web cast will be used for political purposes or campaign.
At the first Tax and Revenue Committee meeting Monday Jan. 26, Arnold-Jones set up her high tech equivalent of a “Dixie cup and a string,” communications device and streamed a live session of the Legislative committee.

Her effort was a hit with some, especially the media and most bloggers.

However, Tax and Revenue Committee Chairman Rep. Ed Sandoval, D, Bernalillo, below right, asked Arnold-Jones twice to shut off her webcam. Sandoval complained that she didn’t ask his permission.

Arnold-Jones stood her ground. Speaker of the House Ben Lujan, D, Santa Fe County, below left, a member of Tax and Revenue, feigned surprise and said he was offended by Arnold-Jones not having had the courtesy of informing him of her plan to stream.

The next day, in a lightening strike response to the webcam, the House Rules and Order of Business Committee, chaired by Rep. Nick L. Salazar, D, Mora, Rio Arriba, San Miguel, Santa Fe and Taos Counties, above sitting to the right of Luján, held it’s first meeting of the session with two agenda items: allowing bolo ties as neckwear for male members on the House floor, and establishing a rule on webcasting.

House rule 2 was cosponsored by the House leadership; House Majority Leader Ken Martinez, left, Cibola, McKinley and San Juan Counties and House Minority Leader Taylor.

The existing House rule reads:
9-5-7
Photography, video or audio recording or transmission of committee proceedings may be allowed with the permission of the chair.
The rule would further amend existing rule 9-10:
The principal duties of the chairman of a committee are:
(b) to preside over meetings of the committee, maintain order and decide all questions of order subject to appeal to a majority of the appointed committee;
New language would be added to subsection b:
...and to ensure that the decorum of the committee is preserved while maximizing the public's ability to observe, report on and participate in a meeting;
There was a long discussion that included the now famous statement by Rep. Ray Begaye, D, San Juan County, where he was concerned that he might be caught sleeping and the video could be used for political purposes against him.

Begaye started with a privacy question, whether a legislator has a privacy interest while fulfilling his legislative duties. He worried allowed about the potential of video being available for sale, redistribution and ultimately used for political mischief by opponents. He said his was an after the fact concern.

Bloggers, print media and KRQE, in particular seized on Begaye’s sitting back in his seat and acting as if he were sleeping to make his point.

Here is Begaye’s entire comment:



"If it's worth doing, it's worth doing right the first time," Rep. Elias Barela, D, Valencia County, said. "I understand the frustration with some members, that we don't have this (webcasting), but just look at the havoc, if one member, of one party, with one ax to grind. And I'm not in any way insinuating that this particular member has that (pointing to Arnold-Jones, standing in the back of the room)." "But, what you're opening up is is something that could be used as a partisan tool."



"Politics is a very open forum," Rep. John Heaton, above left, D, Eddy County, said, "and I think that by being here we have consented to whatever scrutiny anybody wants to apply to us."


"As of Jan. 31, the Albuquerque Journal has discontinued the contracts," Rep. Anna Crook, R, Curry County, said of the suspension of newspaper delivery to the Eastside of the state. "So here we are out here, we can't get the news on satellite, we can't get the newspaper delivery and all. So this is a convince. It's something my constituents, and they have brought this to me. We don't live in Texas."


"We in New Mexico, I, my personal perception, we always have this problem of always with trying to reinvent the wheel," Kathy McCoy, R, Bernalillo, Sandoval and Santa Fe Counties, said."


"Who would actually be doing the webcasting, would there be competition," Rep. Debbie Rodella, Rio Arriba, Sandoval and Taos Counties, asked? "Perhaps an independent third party, or whether it be the council service or somebody else that would take ownership of the webcasting and we wouldn't find ourselves on YouTube this afternoon or tomorrow," she said.


Rep. Keith Gardner, R, Chaves, Eddy, Lea and Roosevelt Counties, engaged Minority Leader Martinez in a discussion about a free press. You will find the debate further down in this posting.

Rep. Danice Picraux, D, Bernalillo County, asked if other states had established rules or guidelines to limit times for speakers in the presence of cameras to ensure decorum.


"I think there should be some mandatory language to the proposed rule which does recognize the discretion of the chairs," Vice Chairman Rep. Joseph Cervantes, D, Dona Ana County, said.


"I'm specifically not against wbecasting," Speaker Luján said.



Chairman Salazar accepted a motion to form a subcommittee to investigate the use of webcasting House activities.


Taylor made a motion, which was seconded by McCoy. He asked that the rule change be adopted in the interim until the sub committee 's report is returned. Adopting the rule would have given clear protection to Arnold-Jones' coverage. Salazar ruled the motion out of order. From a parliamentary stand point there is nothing improper about the motion. The chair chose to rule it out of order because it would officially impose a duty on him to make the previous motion effective.

McCoy, right, and Gardner asked for the subcommittee to return with their report on a date certain. Speaker Luján said he would make the appointments expeditiously.

Based on a fiscal impact report prepared by the Legislative Finance Committee, there is no cost associated with adding the words to the rule.

Legislative Council Service Director Paula Tackett and Assistant Director for Legislative Affairs, John Yaeger, above center conferring with the rule's co-sponsors, Martinez, left and Taylor, right, were instructed to research what other states were doing and to propose a plan for New Mexico.

Arnold-Jones described her disappointment with the delay to members of the press, including KRQE's Kaitlin McCarthy, left.

Speaker Luján appointed a House rules subcommittee, with three Democrats and three Republican.


The Democrats, above, are: House Majority Leader Martinez; Reps. Begaye and Debbie Rodella, Rio Arriba, Sandoval and Taos Counties. The Republican subcommittee members, below, are: Reps. Richard Berry, Bernalillo County; Larry Larrañaga, Bernalillo County; and McCoy.

During this debate, several things have happened beyond the legislative control. In addition to KUNM FM’s audio webcasting, the subscription service, New Mexico Legislative Reports, which acts as the legislative record detailing actions and votes from the floor of both chambers is offering audio webstream to its subscribers and is looking into also providing a video link.


Analysis

The C-SPAN Model

Cable-Satellite Public Affairs Network,housed at the end of this block, is a product of the nations cable operators has been broadcasting the direct coverage provided by the U.S. House of Representatives since 1979 and the Senate in 1986.

Broadcast Coverage of Congress,” are found under, “Rule V, Clause 1, Broadcasting the House.” The rule specifically outlines procedures to provide “complete and unedited audio and visual broadcasting and recording of the proceedings of the House.”

Though Congress has an exclusive agreement with C-SPAN to air the proceedings in the chambers of the House of Representatives and the Senate, nothing prohibits a State from providing coverage of its events directly through its own website, bypassing commercial outlets.

C-SPAN also does it’s own programming which it airs when not showing congressional floor activities.

When you watch C-SPAN and see a committee meeting, White House Press conference, lecture, speeches, studio shows with analysis, call ins, or interviews, with the exception of the of the floor coverage; that material is usually produced by C-SPAN and subject to their own copyright.

C-SPAN sends out crews, like the one above, to cover a 1989 Ethics in Government conference session moderated by Michael Josephson, left, of the Josephson Institute Center. The same Josephson that MacQuigg dealt with for Character Counts.

The crew used two cameras to record the event for later playback.

In the same Washington hotel, the same day, the Democratic Leadership Conference was holding a luncheon where Majority Leader of the U.S. House of Representatives Richard Gephardt, of Mo., above, was giving a speech. C-SPAN also had a two-camera crew covering that event. The camera to the left of Gephardt belongs to C-SPAN; the other is on the press riser, below to the right.

In 30 years, most, if not all the concerns, such as Begaye’s fear, of being caught napping, have been addressed. C-SPAN does not show individual Representatives or Senators who are not addressing their respective bodies.

House rules dictate members behavior in using floor video. The most significant rules are:
c) Coverage made available under this clause, including any recording thereof--
may not be used for any political purpose;
may not be used in any commercial advertisement; and
may not be broadcast with commercial sponsorship except as part of a bona fide news program or public affairs documentary program.
In drafting the three rules: non partisan, picture follows sound, and not for political or campaign use, there is an exception to the rule two.

If you’re old enough to remember streaking, it took ABC’s Wide World of Sports and others several years to figure out that naked men running around sporting event grounds was not part of the sport. Sports television quit showing them; they were not news. Neither are hecklers. So the exception is, if a fight breaks out on the floor, like a Tiwanese debate, where their legislative body has been known to erupt in fisticuffs; then the events should be shown. It is a spur of the moment call that must judiciously be made by the technician who is sufficiently aware and informed to make an appropriate editorial decision

There is a distinction between coverage provided by the government and coverage by a free press. The government’s rules may be applied to their own technicians. However, the First Amendment prohibits government from making and enforcing such rules against a free press.

Rep. Gardner makes his comment and engages Rep. Martinez in a discussion of press rights under the proposed rule. This was the best debate of the day.

Martinez attempts to determine what the press is. He gives an example where he tries to determine that the press is independent. Listen to his story of challenging a person who was documenting a hearing and advocating at the same time.
I asked a person not to videotape, because I asked him, was he here as the press or was he here as an advocate. He said he was the press, then sat down in this chair to argue. I said, now I have a question, are you here to advocate for the bill or here to record it, I said you kind of have to make a decision, because it seems to me that an independent press person would be taking an advocacy position and he said something to the effect, I guess your right and he didn’t say anything and he moved back to videotape again.
Martinez, nor anyone else in government, has the authority to determine who the press is or how they operate. The First Amendment is a prohibition on government. The State’s right is even broader; a person is free to speak, write and publish his sentiments on all subjects. Inherent in the word publish, is the ability to report. Reporting is done through observation, using the five senses and may be augmented by technological devices, like recorders and cameras of all types.

Martinez, using a perverse logic that a person recording a committee meeting had to be the independent press, successfully challenged the man. In his own belief, Martinez had intimidated, bullied or convinced the man that he could not fulfill a dual role.

Note:
First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution

Congress shall make no law respecting the establishment of religion; or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and petition the Government for redress of grievances.
The State of New Mexico’ Constitutional Bill of Right is equally clear:
Sec. 17. Freedom of speech and press; libel.

Every person may freely speak, write and publish his sentiments on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of that right; and no law shall be passed to restrain or abridge the liberty of speech or of the press. In all criminal prosecutions for libels, the truth may be given in evidence to the jury; and if it shall appear to the jury that the matter charged as libelous is true and was published with good motives and for justifiable ends, the party shall be acquitted.

Martinez, has no problem sitting at the witness table with three digital recorders belonging to members of the press in front of him while advocating his rule change before his own committee. Why? Because he also, as a person, as well as a legislator, has the same right to freely speak, write and publish his sentiments on all subjects. It doesn’t matter where you sit or stand.

When Martinez intimidated the advocate he violate four of the six enumerated First Amendment rights: speech, press, assembly or association, and to petition government for redress of a grievance.

There are more publications and communications about issues that attract the general publics' interest than there are, what are commonly referred to as, main stream media outlets. Those who tell the stories or document events are just as protected by the First Amendment as are the more established "journalistic" endeavors.

Begaye’s privacy concern is real to him and to everyone who is in the public eye, but it fails because there is no privacy right in public.

Let me give an example. The following video would never be seen as a webcast under the control of a government. I would normally not run this, except it so aptly demonstrates so many points.

Prior to the start of the House Rules and Order of Business Committee meeting being called to order, while waiting for the arrival of a sufficient number of members to constitute a quorum after the published start time, a little humorous event happened. I was capturing extra video that might be necessary in the editing process to cover broad sweeps of moving from one speaker or to cover an editing of a shortened speech. This extra video is called B-roll and is a routine part of the news story gathering process to cover edits so the picture doesn't jump from one scene to another. Though my original intent was to webcast the committee meeting, one must be prepared for all possible eventualities.

Apparently bored with the wait, Vice Chair Cervantes, started joking. I’ll let the video speak for itself. The participants seen in the video are: Cervantes, Begaye, Salazar and the woman’s voice is Rep. Crook.



A student of psychology might have a field day dissecting that minute or so.

One may see the back room deal expressed openly in the spontaneous utterances of the joke.

Is there a weird deference to power? Cervantes, right, says, “Here comes the real chairman.” Salazar laughingly says, “he can’t do that.” Cervantes blames Begaye, saying, He took over; there was a coupe.”

As much as it might seem that the agenda for the meeting was about bolo ties and webcasting, there were some hidden agendas.

The bolo tie question came about because Sen. John Pinto, D, McKinley and San Juan Counties, tried to visit the House chambers, but was denied entry because he was wearing a bolo tie.

The second hidden agenda item was contained within Rep. Ray Beagaye’s comment about the fear of falling asleep and possibly being shown on a webcast. Beagaye may have been covering again for Pinto, left, who has been known to doze off in the Senate chamber. Pinto has been around since 1977, so he’s pretty much heard it all.

There may have been a third hidden agenda. The House Voters and Elections committee was scheduled to meet, but there was some mutterings from members who sat on both committees of not wanting to attend Voters. Delaying tactics are a common part of the political process and any excuse, good or not, often will do.

Arnold-Jones told the Jan. 31, ConspiracyBrews meeting that she requested the Republicans not attack Begaye’s “sleep” statement in a partisan manner, but the GOP sent House Democrats a basket of coffee with a mug that had a sticker on it, “WAKE UP! Vote Yes on HR-2, Vote yes on transparency. Paid for by the Republicans Party of New Mexico”

Arnold-Jones went on to say that Sen. Pinto was in his 80s and one of only two surviving Navajo code talkers.

I also offer Speaker Lujan’s initial comments on bolo ties.



In praising Rep. James Roger Madalena, left, D, Bernalillo, Mc Kinnley, Rio Arriba and Sandoval Counties, for bringing the bolo tie issue before the rules committee, instead of being confrontational, Luján took another back handed slap at Arnold-Jones, for not having either; asked permission or informed him of her plan to webcast.

Speaker Luján would later end the 40-minute debate with the simple addition of a few words to the decorum rule to allow wearing bolo ties. His suggestion would be turned into a motion and unanimously accepted.

The conciseness of his motion displayed his experience and wisdom brought to bare; it would have been easy to perceive his action as raw political power, when in fact it was a distillation of all that had been said in the preceding 40-minute debate and earlier discussions.

My Take

With over a thousand bills introduced so far this winter, why would I cherry pick this House Rule?

Openness is the key to any ethics reform. The more the public can see, the better informed they are, the better they can understand, and then the better they can influence their representatives.

Fairness in the process is established when every aspect becomes more open.

The House is now halfway to completion of acceptable and appropriate webcasting; it is now audio feeding from the House floor. It has adopted a pilot project to audiocast from select committee rooms. The House still fails because it has not committed itself to video webcasting or creating an archive.

In spite of Speaker Lujan’s protest, in saying Heath Haussamen suggested that he did not support webcasting after initially attacking Arnold-Jones. Lujan’s actions, or more precisely his inactions, taking only a partial step then claiming to have done the proper thing, is much more telling.

““Funny thing is, I never said he 'personally opposed’" it,”" Haussamen wrote in an e-mail, when informed of Lujan’s statement. “I simply said he had killed it in the past by failing to spend the money that was appropriated to the House to purchase and install the equipment to webcast.”

Haussamen wrote, Jan.22:
The only remaining question is whether legislative leaders, including House Speaker Ben Luján, will try to stop her.

Luján hasn’t returned a phone call seeking comment, but it’s no secret that he and other legislative leaders have killed attempts to begin webcasting from the House and Senate floors for years. The Legislature appropriated $75,000 in 2005 to purchase and install the equipment necessary to webcast, but neither chamber has ever appropriated the minimal funding that would be required to operate the equipment.
Luján's comment that he was surprised by Arnold-Jones' webcasting is highly questionable, especially if he was aware of of Haussamen's earlier posting.

Without forcing video webcasting through the House, Luján should rightfully be viewed as an obstructionist in the first step to ethics reform.

Legislative Council Service Director Paula Tackett was given the responsibility to research webcasting, by the House Rules committee.

In watching her respond to reporters’ questions, you’d think this was an issue that just hit her.

Tackett, right, was responsible, since 2005, for assuring that cameras be installed and operated on the Senate side. To feign ignorance is appalling behavior.

A new Senate Bill, the third introduced since 2005, by Sen. Boitano, is sitting on the Senate desk, meaning it’s not moving.

In defending the Senate committee on committees decision not to broadcast, Tackett told New Mexican’s Terell, “…the cameras won't be wasted. They will be in place when the webcasting starts in the future, she said. And they can be used as security cameras.”


There already are a couple hundred security cameras in the Capitol complex. There is a significant difference in picture quality between broadcast and security cameras.

Upon entering the Capitol, citizens are seen on more cameras by security personnel than citizens, for governmental reasons, see legislators.

The issue is being blown out of proportion for political power reasons.

Those with legislative or bureaucratic power dread being forced to work in the light. It’s hard to strong arm and horse trade in the open.

Senate Majority Leader Sanchez is opposed to having the conference committee meet in open session.

The conference committee is arguably the most powerful group in the entire legislative body. Their purpose is to meet and work out the differences that occur in the two versions of a piece of legislation as they were passed in the House and the Senate. The conference committee is entrusted and empowered to negotiate a settlement on language. Members have broad latitude in negotiating.

Opponents to opening the conference committee argue that in order to properly negotiate, all ideas must be examined and sometimes something that might sound silly becomes the impetus to a solution. They contend that having the public eye on them inhibits open discussion.

Proponents of opening the committee sessions say that too often the intent of both bodies are changed so drastically that the original ideas are lost and that deals are made that never would have been acceptable to the public at large if they had been done on the floor of the House or Senate.

Sanchez says that if the conference committee sessions are forced open, members will simply meet outside the committee room prior to the convening and secretly agree to the solutions then act in a pro forma role in accepting what was decided without further public debate.

The House authorized audio webstreaming of its body. They are joining KUNM and New Mexico Legislative Report’s efforts. A problem remains; without knowing the voices of the individual legislators, one cannot tell who is speaking. Video streaming would help solve the problem.

In Congress every word in both chambers and at each committee meeting is copied down and published after every working day as the Congressional Record. When a Representative rises to speak they often ask unanimous consent to extend and revise their remarks in the record. A speaker is often limited to a minute, but then allowed a longer time to revise and extend their entire message. Often times research material, supporting data and reports are also included in the Congressional Record.

Unlike the US government, the New Mexico State Legislature does not create its own record. The Legislature keeps a journal and minutes in committees, which are not the same as a word for word record.

When Congress writes a law, a court may review the legislative history to try to determine the intent. A complete record is therefore very helpful. In New Mexico, courts are not permitted to go beyond the plain language of the statute; meaning they must determine from the law what it should mean. Therefore, having a record is of no assistance to the courts because they may not go and look. However, having a record may serve many other social and political purposes.

Video streaming may constitute the second best record, with an audio being third best.

For public consumption there seem to be two extremes; gavel to gavel coverage backed up with an archive to news coverage and accepting what journalists deem to be the important aspect of stories to be brought to their reader, listeners, or viewers.

A commercial aspect of the national government’s televised coverage comes in the form of C-SPAN. Cable operators charge a fee from their customers, which goes to supporting C-SPAN and also to fund local public, educational and governmental cable access channels, like, GOV TV – Government Television Cable Channel 16, serving the City of Albuquerque and Bernalillo County. GOV-16 uses wall mounted cameras for live and rebroadcast sessions of: County Commission, City Council, City Ethics Board and Police Oversight Commission, among other meetings.

The local franchising authority normally controls public, educational and governmental cable access channels, also known as PEGs.

In the State of Texas, there is a bi-partisan move afoot from 97 members to create a statewide, C-SPAN like outlet.

There is no reason why, during our State’s Legislative sessions and for interim committee meetings, the cable franchises, statewide, couldn’t be compelled to air the State government in action.

The rallying cry is transparency, but that’s not quit accurate. The system is, for the most part, transparent by being open to the public. What is actually being called for is accessibility through a more convenient method.

There is another issue that some believe is critical, though it might not be; that is archiving. The congressional record is kept forever. Of course its storage is the primary reason for the Library of Congress.

Some can make the argument that archiving all state webcasts forever is overkill. The state does have a records retentions act that provides a timetable for purging documents.

Many agencies covered by this act already don’t always follow it. Maybe this discussion will bring to light such deficiencies.

The press, here represented by: New Mexico's Associated Press Bureau Chief and Writer Barry Massey, should always have access to cover, including availability to adequate sound and unobstructed sight lines to provide independent views of the government at work.

One does not have to be reinvent the wheel. The US Senate and House have come up with rules on photographers in committee meetings; they are a little looser than what seems to be practiced in Santa Fe.

Though unobtrusiveness tends to be the guide for most photographers; some will cross over and have not been challenged.

Here, KOB TV's Gadi Schwartz passed the "Legislators & Staff ONLY Beyond This Point" sign to get his shot at the Dec. 8, 2008 Legislative Finance Committee meeting; no one complained.


Final thoughts

Technology has changed since the 1973 Senate Watergate hearings, where New Mexico Sen. Joseph Montoya sat as the junior committeeman to the details of the break in at the National Democratic Party Headquarters in the Watergate complex, below.

Watergate was not the first Congressional hearing to be televised, but it led to the resignation of President Richard Nixon. The public's ability to watch changed a lot of minds.

Today’s technology allows cameras to be less expensive. They are: smaller, more powerful, they operate with less light, and producer higher quality pictures than ever before.

As to the accusation that putting legislative activities on camera will encourage grandstanding; nothing stops legislators from grandstanding now.

Rookie U.S. Congressman Ben R. Luján, Jr. was on C-SPAN a week or so ago with a well prepared, perfectly timed, one minute speech, his first official public utterance from the floor; no grandstanding. Several local blogs: Monahan, Democracy for New Mexico, and NMFBIHOP offered his video:


One might argue that the recent postings of C-SPAN fed House controlled videos might violate the House rules when posted on what are clearly and unabashedly partisan Democratic blog sites; but I won’t. It looks political, but I doubt it violates the spirit of rule as it is also, and probably more accurately of public interest, thereby news.

To those who fear they maybe shown picking their nose, I offer what my Dad taught me; when wearing a suit, carry three handkerchiefs: one for show in the chest pocket, one for yourself, and one for the lady. You don’t have to know who the lady is when you put it in your pocket; you just have to be prepared.

If this State is serious about ridding itself of corruption, the first step is openness.

Anytime you hear anyone make an exception, excuse, or argues against openness consider them an ally of corruption. Don’t allow an advocate for a closed process to say another word until they correct themselves. Unlike the claims of the federal government, the State of New Mexico has no national security interest that must be heard in closed session. There is nothing that every citizen can’t hear.

“Sunshine is the best disinfectant,” Associate Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis said. The legislature has exempted itself from the requirements of the Open Meetings Act.

“The most important political office is that of the private citizen,” Brandeis also said.

Rep Heaton got it right, legislators work for us, the private citizen and we should watch carefully what they do.

Arnold-Jones experiment is a proof of concept. Anything short of a C-SPAN quality effort in both the House and Senate is proof of the most basic form of obfuscation for a corrupt purpose, the intentional deception of the public by keeping them ignorant.

For those interested in attending ConspiracyBrews, here's how the invitation reads:
Rep. Janice E. Arnold-Jones · House District 24
Invites You To
Saturday Morning Office Hours
9:00 AM - 10:30 AM
at Southwest Secondary Learning Center
10301 Candelaria Rd NE
(northwest corner at the intersection of Candelaria and Morris)
(Questions? Call Janice -- 379-0902)
--All Republicans, Democrats, Independents, Libertarians, Greens and others are welcome at all times.--

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Running Shoes or Plodding on?

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

I am more convinced that a saying I like to describe New Mexico politically is truer than ever. “New Mexico; where Democrats act like Republicans and Republicans act like Democrats!”

Democratic State Senator Carlos Cisneros, left, of Los Alamos, Rio Arriba, Santa Fe and Taos Counties was poised to run for the top Senate job, against Sen. Timothy Jennings, of Chaves, Eddy, Lincoln and Otero.

Though Cisneros had on his running shoes and had the backing of the majority of Democratic Senate caucus members, eight crossed over to join all 15 Republicans in reelecting Jennings President Pro Tempore.

The eight Democratic Senators were: Jennings, Linda Lopez, of Bernaillo County, Lynda Lovejoy, Bernaillo, Cibola, Mc Kinley, Rio Arriba, and Sandoval Counties, Howie Morales, of Catron, Grant and Socorro Counties, George Munoz, of Cibola and McKinley Counties, Mary Kay Papen, of Dona Ana County, John Sapien of Sandoval County, and John Arthur Smith, of Hidalgo, Luna and Sierra Counties.

So what’s Wrong With This Picture?

There was a supposed shift in the Progressive Democratic wing of the Party when Republicans lost three seats and a “new breed” soundly defeated some incumbents.

Many Democrats were angry at Jennings, above, for what they saw as crossing Party lines to endorse Republican Senate Minority Whip, Leonard Rawson, of Dona Ana and Sierra counties.

The Party line was that it was all Party. Former NM Democratic Party Chairman John Wertheim, right, took the position that Jennings made an endorsement for Rawson against Party interests.

Blogger Matthew Reichbach on his, New Mexico FBIHOP, site posted the text of the Jennings radio spot:

JENNINGS: I'm Senator Tim Jennings, a Democrat from Chavez, Eddy, Lincoln and Otero Counties. And the elected Pro Tem of the New Mexico state Senate. The Pro Tem ensures that the Senate is run in a fair, efficient manner, and he must work closely with other leaders in the New Mexico Senate, such as Senate Minority Whip Leonard Lee Rawson. While Senator Rawson and I are from different parties and can disagree politically, I must take a stand against the incorrect character assassinations that are being lodged against Senator Rawson. The accusations against him are unproved and unfair.

RAWSON: I'm Leonard Lee Rawson and I approve this message.
Jennings took the position that Rawson, right, was attacked with lies as a sitting Senator, and that as leader of the Senate, he had a responsibility to defend the institution.

Wertheim’s examples of other attacks that he thought Jennings should have commented on were beyond the narrow position of protecting the Senate.

The best analysis of the infighting, I found, came from Professor Jose Garcia’s “La Politica: New Mexico! La Voz del Valle del Sur”

Rawson lost to Stephen Fischmann.

Republicans elected William Payne, right, Bernallilo County, Senate Minority Whip.

Despite the numeric imbalance between the Democrats and Republicans, the leadership tends to mirror the actual sense of the feelings of New Mexicans, stripped of the political cloth – moderate to mildly conservative. The Republicans will go along to assure that the more liberal wings of the Democratic Party, especially the Progressives, do not take control.

Tuesday, January 13, 2009

What you missed

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

I posted about Capitol Report New Mexico’s return and noted the Legislative Finance Committee’s report on the state of the projected budget.

In covering the story, I went to two meetings in Santa Fe last month, photographing the Dec. 8, LFC meeting and the Dec. 18, pre-session Legislative seminars and new member orientation.

With print medium, space is limited by the dimensions of the pages. There are events that occur which cannot be shown because of editorial considerations. The beauty of this blog; I can go deeper. Here's what you missed.

So what’s wrong with this picture?

There were two sessions on Dec 18: the consensus general fund report, given by Department of Finance and Administration Secretary Katherine Miller, followed by the current fiscal year solvency plan, where Legislative Finance Committee’s Director, David Abbey, joined Miller. Speaker of the House, Representative Ben Lujan, D, Santa Fe County, and Senate President Pro Tempore Timothy Z. Jennings, D, Chaves, Eddy, Lincoln and Otero Counties, sat with Miller and Abbey during their presentations.

The projected numbers seemed staggering and at least two legislators’ jaws dropped.

Newly-elected Sen. Eric Griego, D, Bernalillo County and Rep. Candy Spence Ezzell, R, Chaves County, responded to hearing the numbers during Miller’s briefing.

One can only imagine what great legislative initiative died in these legislators' minds as realization hit the ugly wall of truth; there is no money.

Monday, January 12, 2009

Spin Control at the Street Level

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

After posting the Matthew Astorga piece Dec. 30, 2008, I received comments, including the following anonymous offering, posted here without editing.
While it is importnat to remember that a life has been taken, I think it is also important to report the whole story. Mr. Rodriguez stabbed Matthew in the back twice, barely missing his artery only days before "they" say Matthew killed him. A couple of days after this stabbing, the family home of Matthew which he shared with his wife, mother, and two small children was shot at. Mr. Rodriguez was a member of "La Eme" A California Prison gang. What was he doing in Kansas anyway? Calling Matthew wife and threating her... threating to kill Matthews whole family... Why are these things not being reported?

Really... why is this making it to the Albuquerque media outlets? Because Michael is still awaiting trial? Seems the criminal justice system doesnt care about innocent until proven guilty. And neither does the media
(Anonymous) 1/4/09
Which led to my posting the follow up. I wanted the information to be brought into the public discussion.

The comment sections of the newspaper sites, both the Leavenworth Times and San Gabriel Valley Tribune, where there was a reporter written obituary, had discussions about the two men and their families. I realized that there was an effort to go beyond the news accounts, to put a face, a personality on the bare facts of the stories. The effort seemed to be the equivalent of spin control.

I threw down the gauntlet about posting comments anonymously.

I spoke with Leavenworth County Under Sheriff Ron Cranor. He had no direct information and did not think his Department had any contact with either Matthew Astorga or Ruben Rodriguez and directed me to the Leavenworth Police Department as the lead investigative organization.

I forwarded the anonymous allegations to the public information officer of the Leavenworth Police Department, Major Robert Smith. Smith responded:
We are well aware of all of these events. Although, your poster is apparently not concerned with accuracy of information. Matthew was not stabbed in the back twice, nor was he stabbed by Rodriguez. The stabbing was reported, but not by Astorga, he would tell us nothing. His wound was minor and he refused medical treatment. Astorga does not live in our city so the alleged shooting was not reported to us. It was called in but not reported to any law enforcement officials. When Sheriff's arrived they could find no evidence of a shooting and no one would talk.
The factual accuracy of the anonymous statements came into question.

I received another comment, this time signed by Christy Armell.
I am honestly tired of the media only showing one side of things. This is how the juctice system tries to ensure that the defendants do not receive a fair trial, which is a right that is guaranteeed by our consititution. So many people rely on the media for correct information. It is a blind person who beleives what they see on TV as the whole truth.

The man that Matthew is accused of killing, stabbed Matthew only days before this situation. A day after the stabbing, of which Matthew was air-lifted to a hospital to help save his life, the family home was shot at. This home included a wife and two small children.

The alledged victim is a known gang member for California. Why was he in Kansas to begin with? And why has the media not covered what the truth is regarding this man?

I am sorry for the loss of this man, but the truth is the truth. Threating phone calls to the family, and threats made of murder of family members in court need to be addressed as well.

I also wonder why this blog is even being maintained by someone in Albuquerque. This alleged crime occured in Kansas, and really has no bearing on what is happening in New Mexico. Matthews brother, Michael is awaiting trial in NM, and it seems that any type of media outlet will work to bring the Astorga name into the mud, and into the spotlight once again. These are the same people who argue that our justice system is fair and just! Nothing is fair about what the media has protrayed regarding this family.
(christy armell) 7:46 PM 01/06/09
So what’s wrong with this picture?

Armell is a full time student through the on-line campus of the University of Phoenix majoring in criminal justice who will graduate in May. She is also an Anti Death Penalty Activist.

In a telephone interview, Armell said she wrote the anonymous comment and rewrote the signed version to comply with this site’s policy.

Armell is a friend of Theresa Romero, mother of Matthew, his brother Michael Paul Astorga and another son, Anthony Lucero. She has provided moral support to Romero and her family; she attended court for Michael Astorga’s pre-trial hearings and says she writes or visits him on a weekly basis.

Armell went to Kansas after the shooting death of Ruben Rodriguez in Leavenworth. Matthew Astorga was arrested and charged with first-degree murder, felon in possession of a handgun and fleeing or eluding police. These are all felonies. 

Armell spoke with Matthew, but did not ask him who stabbed him. “He talked about it (the stabbing), but I didn’t ask questions,” Armell said.

Armell is concerned that local press coverage sensationalizes the brothers and makes it difficult to find an impartial jury in Albuquerque for the up coming trial of Michael Paul Astorga, who is charged with killing Bernalillo County Deputy Sheriff James Mcgrane Jr.

Michael Paul Astorga was already a fugitive at the time, wanted on another murder warrant for the November 2005 shooting death of Candido Martinez, described as a childhood friend, according to press accounts at the time.

Michael Paul Astorga’s Attorney, Gary Mitchell, has argued unsuccessfully for a change of venue in the case where the State, through local District Attorney Kari Brandenburg, seeks the death penalty.

Armell is not the only one trying to spin the personalities of the two men who came together on December 26, on the front lawn of 900 Cheyenne St. in Leavenworth, a house only five blocks from the federal penitentiary. She is attempting to shield the public from such news to protect Astorga’s brother.

The dead man, Ruben Rodriguez, 50, was a California native, from Asuza. According to family members, he was addicted to heroin and was arrested for bank robbery at age 17. After serving time, he was involved in trying to help rehabilitate gang members. He moved to Missouri, then Kansas to escape his past.

Analysis

Members of both families and their friends are using the comment sections of the media to express their thoughts, memories, feelings and loss.

The comments are found amongst hate filled accusations of all sorts of unsubstantiated rumors and speculation.

Armell asks some fair questions while embedding them in a less than candid recitation of what happened. She asserted that Rodriguez stabbed Matthew twice in the back. However, when pressed, she changed the story. Armell said she had conflicting information as to who did the stabbing; one source named Rodriguez, another did not know. Matthew told Armell that he did not know who stabbed him. She also changed the location of the stab wounds from, two in the back to one in the back and the other in the neck, just missing the jugular.

When asked about the police statement that the wound was minor and Astorga had refused medical treatment, she confirmed the part about refusing treatment by an ambulance and said that his mother, Romero, drove him to a local hospital where he was airlifted to a Kansas City trauma center. He was treated and released, according to Armell. She was unclear about when the stabbing occurred in relation to the shooting, but thought it was two or three days earlier.

Armell had only scant information about the house being shot at; she did know that it was not struck. Armell offered no information about the source or details of any threatening phone calls.

The First Amendment is a prohibition against government limiting speech and the press from having wide-ranging discussion on all manner of topics. Little has been deemed by the courts to be off limits.

The Sixth Amendment is the requirement that government provides an accused a fair trial.

The First and Sixth Amendments stand in stark conflict.

Government, through its police and prosecutors, may not try a case in public.

In emotional and high profile cases, it’s hard for some in government to exercise restraint. Yet, at the same time, government has an obligation to help inform the public through their cooperation with a free press. Disseminating facts about incidents are a critical part of societal needs. Even one of the principles of policing established by Sir Robert Peel was that crime news must be widely distributed.

What police and prosecutors write in documents filed in court are considered fair game for press coverage. What is generally considered improper is speculation or opinion about what facts might mean.

My Take

What I found fascinating is the level of spin placed on the stories that are meant to shade the public’s perception of the various participants.

The Internet levels access for the public that is usually filtered by the news media. The press is a filter on what is deemed important, necessary and newsworthy.

Much of the public will still rely on corporate media to act as their filter. Journalists have a duty to determine what news to report. It is a juggling act; determine what the public wants to know and also determine what the public needs to know. The authors of the First Amendment understood the crucial nature of open and public debate and the need to assure political speech. To protect political speech, the drafters of the Bill of Rights knew that all speech must be protected.

“Informed public discussion is essential to wise policy,” wrote the chief architect of the First Amendment, James Madison.

The press is simply an extension of speech. Thomas Jefferson in 1787, before the Constitution was written, himself wrote:
The basis of our governments being the opinion of the people, the very first object should be to keep that right; and were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.
190 years ago today, January 12, 1819, Jefferson who was also no great fan of newspapers, in a letter to Nathaniel Macon wrote:
I read no newspaper now but Ritchie's, and in that chiefly the advertisements, for they contain the only truths to be relied on in a newspaper.
“I am honestly tired of the media only showing one side of things,” Armell wrote.

News normally is not about the ordinary day to day lives of people going about their business. However, news is certainly about the deaths of people. In a paper of record, a common citizen may expect to see their name in print three times: for their birth, their wedding announcement, and as an obituary.

Matthew Astorga has been convicted, and he ultimately pled guilty, after an appeal of the murder conviction was overturned and returned to District Court for retrial, of the 1996 killing of Jose Maldonado Sigala in Martineztown, near downtown Albuquerque. His brother, Michael Paul who was present at the shooting, was also charged in that case and was acquitted by the jury. Subsequently, he’s been charged with murder in the two previously mentioned events. Astorgas’ half brother, Lucero is serving a life prison sentence for murdering a fellow soldier. Amongst three family members; they have been convicted of or charged in connection with five deaths. These facts alone constitute news when it comes to the attention of a local journalist.

News can also be personal. I am going to write about Matthew and Michael Astorga because they touched me. I stood over a complete stranger, Maldonado Sigala, and watched as his life ebbed away. I was helpless in any effort to stem the blood flow from the multiple shotgun wounds. He died shortly after being taken to the hospital.

I hope I’ve given as much of the other side of the story that Armell and others might want.

The criminal justice system will take up the allegations and juries will render their verdicts in due course.

Hopefully, the citizenry is adequately informed of what happens in our community or what our hometown residents are doing.

We’re Back

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

Publisher/Editor Harold Morgan announced the return of Capitol Report New Mexico after a one-year hiatus; we will be back as a newspaper.

CRNM was launched two years ago as a magazine and ran its course for a year.
The group working on the project then looked into the possibility of publishing on line.

The name Capitol Report New Mexico was kept alive as a blog, posted by Morgan.

Monday, Capitol Report New Mexico will be distributed to Legislators, government officials at the State, County and municipal levels, along with lobbyists and selected participants in the governmental process.

The tabloid-sized paper is funded with financial support from the Rio Grande Foundation, a think tank based in Albuquerque. Except for a page reserved for the Foundation, the editorial content is based on the original precepts of the magazine.

So what’s wrong with this picture?

We’re starting from a hole in the ground, literally and figuratively, just like the new Capitol parking structure. We have nowhere to go, but up.

As a niche publication, we tend to focus on the details of the legislative budget process and are first to publish the Legislative Finance committee’s report on their solvency plan for the 2009 fiscal year, officially released today .

The new edition has the same guest columnists as the magazine had: an analysis of the 2008 election by Lonna Atkeson, Tidbits from La Politica with Jose Z. Garcia, and Tax Policy Issues with Richard L. Anklam.

I provided the photographs. For all the fancy electronic media bells and whistles, there is something about black ink on “dead tree” newsprint that I like.

The paper will be posted in pdf form, later in the week, at Capitol Report NM.com.

Sunday, January 11, 2009

Yates Jr. Wins GOP Chair

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

The New Mexico State Republican Party’s Central Committee elected Harvey Yates Jr. as their next chairman, Saturday, to replace Col. Allen Weh, who did not run.

Yates beat Dr. Allen McCulloch, left, who ran for the U.S. Senate against Jeff Bingaman in 2006 and lost, and political novice Michael Meyer, right, who is a managing director of an Albuquerque investment advisory firm. Former State Legislator John Padoven withdrew from the race Thursday, throwing his support to Yates.

So what’s wrong with this picture?

There was no tally of the vote and numbers were not immediately available.

In addition to the election of the party leadership, six rules amendments were voted on and five failed, including the adoption of parliamentary order.

Further analysis will be posted when the Party provides the complete figures.

Though welcomed to cover the Central Committee event, I was ejected from a post meeting session called by Yates with Legislators and selected Party members by Communications Director and acting Executive Director Whitney Cheshire, left, with Weh, prior to the adjournment of the main meeting.

This is in conflict with Yates' campaign statements and the Rules Of The Republican Party As adopted by the 2004 Republican National Convention August 30, 2004.
BE IT RESOLVED, That the Republican Party is the party of the open door. Ours is the party of liberty, the party of equality of opportunity for all and favoritism for none.
It is the intent and purpose of these rules to encourage and allow the broadest possible participation of all voters in Republican Party activities at all levels and to assure that the Republican Party is open and accessible to all Americans.
I have no reason to believe that Yates was aware of Cheshire's action or that he would have approved. In his speech, accepting the nomination, he spoke of transparency.

Monday, January 05, 2009

Just Reporting the News

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

I have taken a position with this blogsite that I want to have a civil discussion.

However, part of my approach is that I won’t engage with the very prolific “anonymous.”

My site doesn’t generate a lot of comments, but about one in five are “anonymous.” A while back, I changed my policy by indicating that “anonymous” comments will no longer be posted.

Here’s the problem; some of the “anonymous” comments are worthy of sharing. I don’t need to know exactly who is responding on this site.

In the public square, one gets to see who is speaking and then judge from their demeanor just how much credibility to give the responder. Without having an identifier, any anonymous becomes every anonymous. Anonymous becomes a blur of multiple personalities.

I request that comment posters who are unwilling to use their name adopt a screen name so my readers and I have an idea of who is communicating.

Part of what I do here is to try to introduce my readers to the players in the public square, be they: politicians, journalists, those making news and the “every man story maker,” who are the topics of this blog.

So I ask that if you wish to add to the discussion, please adopt a screen name, so my readers and I can keep track of the participants. I revert to the program seller at sporting events hawking their product by yelling, “you can’t tell the players without a program.”

So what’s wrong with this picture?

What’s news? It’s more than just the products found under the kiosk sign of a newsstand, like this one at Washington National Airport. News is a wide range of information that people want to know about or should know about or need to know about in order to be a well informed citizen.

Mark Twain a newspaper reporter, editor and publisher may have said it best:
If you don't read the newspaper you are uninformed, if you do read the newspaper you are misinformed.
After posting the story on Matthew Astorga’s activities in the Leavenworth, Kan. area, I received an anonymous comment. The person relates a fractured story with little detail. It raises potential self defense claims that I will try to verify. It is journalistically unethical to publish unsubstantiated assertions.

This particular anonymous, who seems to be from Kansas, asks two questions about their claims of facts:
Why are these things not being reported??
Really... why is this making it to the Albuquerque media outlets?
The reason the allegations made by anonymous is not being reported is, no one knew until now.

Why the Astorga story made it to the Albuquerque media outlets is because crime, especially with a local hook, is always news.

I am not a great fan of the “news scoop,” the title given to the first media outlet to report a particular story. It’s partly based on human nature, of wanting to know what is happening right now, and part marketing ploy to bragging rights.

I believe that getting the story right and putting it into proper context is also important. Breaking news does not always allow for the time necessary to understand the deeper meaning of the headlines of developing stories.

The nature of the news business is changing. The local newspapers, though being challenged by the Internet, mobile phones and personal electronic devices, are still as viable products in our society as are the postal system. E-mail, text-messaging, and twittering may speed our written communications, but it hasn't made the post box obsolete. Contrary to any complaints about how hard it is for papers to survive in the current economic climate, they still are turning profits in the range of 15 to 20 percent. There are lots of industries that would love to bemoan such profit rates.

The Leavenworth Times posted this story Dec. 30, along with a follow up Jan. 2, on their website. Someone listed my story in the Times comment section. I was sent an e-mail by a Times reader, about the story.

Stories about the Astorga's of Albuquerque are news.

I believe I was the first local media with this story and posted a little before 1 p.m. MST, though Blogger time stamp indicated 1:57 p.m.

I gave the story to my buddy, Peter St. Cyr at KKOB. He went on air at 5 PM and posted to his site, “What’s the Word?” at 4:43 p.m. I provide images for his site.

In an ad-hoc unscientific experiment, to see how this story might spread, I also sent an e-mail to Sheriff Darren White. That evening, the only TV station to run the story was KRQE. White was a crime reporter at KRQE before being elected Sheriff.

The Albuquerque Journal’s T.J. Wilham ran the story the next morning citing the Times article.

I did some follow up with Leavenworth Times reporter John Richmeier and learned Wilham had called him after 5 p.m. Wednesday. Thursday, other media started catching up. My blogging colleague Sgt. Joe Schmedlap, who had his own previous contact with the Astorgas, posted his own story.

Though I credited my sources, nobody except St. Cyr did. Scooping is cutthroat.

Santa Fe Reporter's Editor Julia Goldberg, in her Blog, has repeatedly complained about her staff writing original stories that other media copy and rewrite without acknowledging their source.

I agree with Goldberg that source identification is important and should be done with greater regularity.

Sunday, January 04, 2009

Political News Flash: Full Stop!

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

New Mexico Democratic Governor Bill Richardson tapped by President-elect Barack Obama for Secretary of Commerce has withdrawn his nomination according to MSNBC’s Andrea Mitchell.

So what’s wrong with this picture?

Richardson is the subject of a secret grand jury, reportedly over charges of a possible pay-to-play scheme with a California investment company CDR Financial Products.

CDR, a contributor to Richardson’s political campaigns received a sole source contract in 2003 with the New Mexico Finance Authority and pocketed $1.4 million in fees over bond deals. The State claimed the deal had saved the public $8 million.

Richardson ran for the Democratic Presidential nomination and withdrew just under a year ago. The Gov. backed Obama and upset the Hilary Clinton campaign.

Richardson was the Ambassador to the United Nations and Secretary of Energy under President Bill Clinton. Previously he was elected seven times to Congress from the then newly created northern New Mexico District.

Richardson will remain as Governor and plans to complete his remaining two years.

His anticipated departure to Washington would have meant that Lt. Gov. Diane Denish, left, seen the day before the Nov. 5 election, would become Governor upon his confirmation.

This development will have political ramifications on both sides of the political aisle.

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

Matthew Astorga

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

There is no picture. However, picture this; Matthew Astorga of rural Lansing, Kan., was arrested in Leavenworth, Kan., charged with first-degree murder, felon in possession of a firearm and fleeing or eluding police.

So what’s wrong with this picture?

It has a familiar ring to it....

Leavenworth Times Reporter John Richmeier wrote of a Matthew Astorga being arrested.

Is this the same Matthew Astorga, brother of Michael Paul Astorga, who is accused of, and is awaiting trial in the death of Bernalillo County Deputy Sheriff James McGrane Jr.? McGrane was shot to death during a traffic stop on March 22, 2006,

Google search is a wonderful resource. Type in a name and voila, up pops a list of links to information on that request.

I got an e-mail from a man who had gone looking for additional information on Astorga.

My May 2006 posting was number one on the Google list. I posted the man's name, but he's requested anonymity. I'm breaking my rule on using an anonymous source; though he is actually an unnamed source. He was none-to-happy about the reported crime.

I read you article on title "Whats wrong with this picture" and the Astorgas. Last Friday, Matthew Astorga murdered a man in Leavenworth, Ks. He's chargd with 1st degree murder and has a 1 million dollar bond. I'm not sure the judge reaizes when this gets bail, he's gone! I was amazed that he is a former murderer with such an obtainable bond.

How our local law enforcement did not know this guy was living and no doubt "dealing" in our community and is a convicted felon amazes me!

The City of Leavenworth Police are of the belief that the man they have is the Astorga of Albuquerque.

Kansas City's KHSB NBC Action News reports Astorga was from New Mexico. Other Local television, KCTV 5 news reports give more details

Astorga was living in Lansing, a neighboring town of Leavenworth; just northwest of Kansas City.